Back to map
Home/US lakes/Idaho/Horsethief Reservoir

Horsethief Reservoir

Idaho
1.00 km²
44.5110, -115.9158
13 species
NHD 42401455
Open interactive map →
Imagery © Esri
View on map Google Maps Apple Maps

Find a fishing partner near Horsethief Reservoir

Match with other anglers nearby, share the boat, learn from each other and become better fishermen together — free to join.

Open Fishing BuddyExplore the fishing map

About Horsethief Reservoir

Horsethief Reservoir is a natural lake or pond in Idaho, United States. It covers approximately 1.00 km² (247 acres). The lake centroid is located at 44.5110° N, 115.9158° W. 13 fish species are commonly found in waters like this one, including 2 introduced species. Lake boundary and identifier come from the USGS National Hydrography Dataset.

At a glance

Best season
May – September
Ice-off through early fall
Natural lake
Medium
Great for a day trip
Species diversity
Diverse
13 species in this region
Access
Public waterbody
Check Idaho fishing regulations

Weather at Horsethief Reservoir

Loading forecast…

Best fishing times today

Day length: 9h 25m
Dawn14:16
Sunrise14:48
Sunset00:13
Dusk00:45

Bite windows today

  • Dawn13:46 – 15:48Excellent
  • Morning15:48 – 19:30Good
  • Midday19:30 – 21:13Calm
  • Afternoon21:13 – 23:13Good
  • Dusk23:13 – 01:15Excellent
  • Night01:15 – 13:46Good
Moon: 86% · waxing↑ 22:05

Fish species

Species data comes from GBIF and is refreshed by donors.Support this →

Showing 13 of 13 species

  • Lake Trout
    Salvelinus namaycush
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Rainbow Trout
    Oncorhynchus mykiss
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →Species guide & fishing tips →
  • Crappie
    Pomoxis
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Yellow Perch
    Perca flavescens
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Northern Pike
    Esox lucius
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Smallmouth Bass
    Micropterus dolomieu
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Largemouth Bass
    Micropterus salmoides
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Channel Catfish
    Ictalurus punctatus
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Bluegill / Sunfish
    Lepomis
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Brown Trout
    Salmo trutta
    0 records
    Introduced
    Explore lakes with this species →Species guide & fishing tips →
  • Brook Trout
    Salvelinus fontinalis
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Walleye
    Sander vitreus
    0 records
    Explore lakes with this species →
  • Common Carp
    Cyprinus carpio
    0 records
    Introduced
    Explore lakes with this species →

Gear & tips for rainbow trout

Rod
5- to 7-weight fly rod
Sage X
Vision XO
Loop Q
Reel
5/6-weight fly reel
Mainline
WF-5/6 floating line + intermediate
Leader
Tapered + 0.20 mm tippet
Lures / bait
  • Streamers
  • Egg patterns
  • Nymphs
  • Dry flies
  • Boobies
Find fly fishing gear at Sportfish
Season
April–November (put-and-take year-round)
Time of day
All day
Tip

Put-and-take fishing is common. Vary your depth. Popular Swedish waters: Bunn, Sommen and many small stocked put-and-take ponds.

Full guide

Plan your trip to Horsethief Reservoir

Everything you need before you launch — license, regulations, and current water conditions.

Buy Idaho fishing license
Idaho Fish & Game
Water conditions & levels
USGS gauge data near Horsethief Reservoir
Browse more fishing tips from the community

Plan a fishing day trip

How far are you willing to drive? We'll show other Idaho lakes within your range.

50 mi
  • Corral Creek Reservoir3 mi
  • Warner Pond3 mi
  • Davis Reservoir4 mi
  • Calendar Reservoir5 mi
  • Jemima K Reservoir7 mi
  • East Mountain Reservoir9 mi

Nearby lakes

  • Corral Creek Reservoir
    5.4 km away · 0.13 km² · ID
  • Warner Pond
    4.6 km away · 0.06 km² · ID
  • Davis Reservoir
    5.9 km away · 0.35 km² · ID
  • Calendar Reservoir
    7.9 km away · 0.09 km² · ID
  • Jemima K Reservoir
    10.6 km away · 0.34 km² · ID
  • East Mountain Reservoir
    14.0 km away · 0.08 km² · ID
See all fishing lakes in Idaho →
Sponsor this lake

For $5/month you help keep species, boundaries and coordinates fresh for 35 000+ lakes. FishMap is independent and community-funded.

Become a supporter →

A business wanting to appear here? Advertise & partner →

Frequently asked questions

What fish species live in Horsethief Reservoir?

Species you can expect in or near Horsethief Reservoir include Lake Trout, Rainbow Trout, Crappie, Yellow Perch, Northern Pike, Smallmouth Bass, Largemouth Bass, Channel Catfish, and others. The list is based on species present in Idaho waters and GBIF occurrence records.

How big is Horsethief Reservoir?

Horsethief Reservoir covers approximately 1.00 square kilometres (247 acres), based on the USGS National Hydrography Dataset.

Where is Horsethief Reservoir located?

Horsethief Reservoir is located in Idaho, United States, with its centroid at 44.5110°, -115.9158°.

The right gear makes the difference

Ad

Sportfish is one of the UK's leading fishing tackle retailers, with a wide range of rods, reels, lures and fly-tying gear. We recommend them if you're looking to upgrade your setup.

Shop at Sportfish

Photography and fishing go hand in hand

Ad
10% off Retropia

A good catch photo turns a session into a memory. The soft, grainy disposable-camera look — captured optically with Retropia's lens — gives an ordinary fish picture real character. Get 10% off through the link in our photo guide, no code needed.

Read the photo guide

Data sources: USGS National Hydrography Dataset · GBIF